SPEAK NO EVIL

September 13, 2024

james mcavoy, james watkins, mackenzie davis, scoot mcnairy, speak no evil

Words by JANE CROWTHER


Those who experienced 2022’s Danish horror of the same name may not wish to revisit the particular trauma of that movie, taking in mutilation, social discomfort and a bleakness that snatched breath. A disquieting hit at Sundance, Speak No Evil pitched a Danish couple against a Dutch couple – leveraging middle-class politeness to devastating effect. Now writer/director James Watkins recasts and re-sets the tale in Britain under the Blumhouse shingle, with a reserved American couple, Louise and Ben (Mackenzie Davis and Scoot McNairy), meeting a brash Brit duo, Paddy and Ciara (James McAvoy and Aisling Franciosi), on holiday in Tuscany. Both pairs have kids of a similar age and though they probably wouldn’t usually gel as friends, an alliance is formed and invites to weekends in the country are extended post-vacation. Despite Louise’s misgivings, the American family travels to a rustic farmhouse where Paddy flips from gregarious host to seething bully and back, and the kids discover something terrible in the basement…

james mcavoy, james watkins, mackenzie davis, scoot mcnairy, speak no evil

To discuss specifics of the horror is to spoil the experience of an incremental discomfort for audiences as social niceties are tested to the limit. At what point, Watkins asks throughout, would YOU say something? What inappropriate action, unpleasant comment, disregard of personal values would be the tipping point to cast judgement? As Paddy and Ciara display boorish, cruel and ultimately sinister behaviour, Louise and Ben are forced to confront the unspoken trauma hidden in their own marriage, as well as question their liberal credentials.

That tonal tightrope rests on the performance of Paddy, here essayed by McAvoy, bringing all his charming and venal charisma to the role – delightfully chummy one minute, a savage the next. It’s a monstrously entertaining turn in his hands and one that makes a revised ending work despite softening the nihilism and inhumanity of the original. It also allows more agency for Davies, playing a spikier version of the first film’s fussy wife, a woman who can, and will, bring her own barbarity to the fore when required. As a brisk, assured social horror (with plenty of vengeful tool use) Speak No Evil is a satisfying scare. But those that can bear the terrible sadness and appalling use of secateurs, should also seek out Christian Tafdrup’s urtext version. And hug your children twice as hard after watching either…

james mcavoy, james watkins, mackenzie davis, scoot mcnairy, speak no evil

Words by JANE CROWTHER
Speak No Evil is in cinemas now

You may also like…

Cartier, Gladiator II, Greg Williams, Gucci, Hamnet, Paul Mescal

PAUL MESCAL

Photographs by GREG WILLIAMSInterview by GREG WILLIAMS & JANE CROWTHER Gladiator II’s Paul Mescal saddles up to discuss the emotional, psychological and physical ride of acting

lucy boynton, the pale blue eye, the ipcress file, chevalier, hollywood authentic, greg williams, greg williams photography

LUCY BOYNTON

How important is a little bit of nonsense now and then to you?A daily necessity for the sake of sanity. What, if anything, makes you believe